RecallMed

Practice questions › Biostatistics and ethics

Gillick competence and the Fraser guidelines: practice question

Biostatistics and ethics · exam-style question with a full explanation

A 15-year-old girl asks her GP for contraception. She is in a relationship with a 16-year-old boy and will not tell her parents. She understands the advice and the risks, and the GP thinks she is likely to continue having sex. What should the GP do?

  1. A. Refuse until she is 16
  2. B. Inform her parents before prescribing
  3. C. Prescribe if she is competent and meets Fraser criteria
  4. D. Report the boy to the police in every case
  5. E. Prescribe only with a court order
Show the answer and explanation

Answer: C. Prescribe if she is competent and meets Fraser criteria

In the UK, a young person under 16 can consent if they have enough maturity and understanding (Gillick competence). For contraception, the Fraser guidelines apply: she understands the advice, cannot be persuaded to tell her parents, is likely to have sex anyway, her health would suffer without contraception, and it is in her best interests. Keep confidentiality unless there is a safeguarding concern (such as a large age gap, coercion, exploitation or a partner in a position of trust). Laws differ elsewhere: many US states allow minors to consent to contraception.

Why not the other options

  • Refusing or informing parents: breaches the rights of a competent young person.
  • Reporting a peer of similar age: not automatically required.
  • Court order: not needed.

Key point: sexual activity under 13 always raises safeguarding concerns, since a child of that age cannot legally consent.

Practise more questions like this, free →
Free to start. Unlimited practice from $1.99 (KES 150) a week.

More biostatistics and ethics questions

All biostatistics and medical ethics practice questions → · All free questions →

RecallMed is independent and is not affiliated with, or endorsed by, any university, licensing body or examining board. Questions on this site are original, written for revision practice, and are not a substitute for your course materials or clinical guidelines.